Vigilante - Is Caughtya.org "vigilantism"?

Some people are referring to caughtya.org as promoting "vigilante" behaviour. Viewing the site as something negative. Let's get this straight: Caughtya does not promote vigilante behaviour. Further than that - people taking photos for and submitting them to the site are not vigilantes. They are witnesses to public violations of the law, but they do not violate any laws themselves. Nor does this site.

What is a vigilante?

Wikipedia defines vigilante as:

A vigilante is someone who illegally punishes someone for perceived offenses, or participates in a group which metes out extralegal punishment to such a person.

That seems a clear definition of the word. It is also very close to many other reference sites and dictionaries.

  1. Caughtya does not punish people - The publication of a photo of a car parked in plain view on the web does not constitute punishment.
  2. Neither taking, nor posting, photos is illegal.
  3. There is no "perceived" offense - either a mobility parking permit is displayed, or it is not. This is pretty clear cut, it has nothing to do with interpretation or perception.
  4. There are no "group meeting" of people submitting photos to Caughtya.
  5. As there is no punishment, it is not possible to be illegal or extralegal.

Seems to me that it is a pretty straightforward concept.

Caughtya is not vigilante

Wikipedia adds:

Members of community watch programs and others who use legal means of bringing people to justice are not considered vigilantes. For example, in 1979 Curtis Sliwa founded the Guardian Angels in New York City, a recognized crime fighting organization that now has chapters in many other cities.

Once again, Caughtya does not bring people to justice. And its actions are legal. There is nothing illegal about taking a photo of a car parked in public view. There is nothing illegal about publishing such a photo.

Wikipedia continues:

Vigilante behavior may differ in degree of violence. In some cases vigilantes may assault targets verbally, physically attack them or vandalize their property. Anyone who defies the law to further justice is a vigilante, and thus violence is not a necessary criterion.

We do not assault people, verbally or physically. We do not vandalise their car, not even by putting sticky flyers on their cars.

We WILL not act illegally in the process of exposing cars illegally parked in disability parking spaces without permits. Simple as that.

Caughtya.org does NOT encourage vigilante behaviour. I am not a vigilante.And nor are the others who use the site to share photos of people in public view breaking the law.

Post Details:
This entry was posted on Wednesday, March 4th, 2009 and is filed under Drive-by. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

Tags:
, , , ,

 

Comments are closed.

 
 

Latest Comments

Toyota Prius, plate FFB361, in Christchurch, canterbury, New Zealand

Comment by: Webmaster
The taxi company was contacted and their general manager is going to look into it. He said: "If you have any additional information on the date and time of this incident I would welcome the receipt of that so we can identify the driver concerned at the time and address the matter with them directly.

Nissan , plate ABQ227, in Waikanae, New Zealand

Comment by: Webmaster
I may not buy more in one go, but I guarantee you I spend as much, if not more, than the average punter does in a week.

Nissan , plate ABQ227, in Waikanae, New Zealand

Comment by: Dirk
By that i mean they have few issues pushing around large food carts.

 

Twitter

@natedogg1229

Catchin people snoozing in class is always hilarious #caughtya

@msgoodgood2012

Lying is a snowball effect 1nce tell 1 u have to keep tellin it its easier to tell the truth than it is to remember ya lies #CaughtYa lol

@MaryHall13

just saw a kid pick his nose and eat it in my observation #caughtya

@xChristiana

People do weird shit in their cars when they think no one is looking. #caughtya

@

@EvinDanger u r driving behind me belting out a song hehe #caughtya

Powered by WP-TwitterSearch